Three Years Under Florida’s 50/50 Time-Sharing Presumption: What Appellate Courts Say It Takes to Overcome It

Since July 1, 2023, Florida judges have started contested parenting cases from the same place: the assumption that equal time with each parent is best for the child. Three years in, appellate courts have had plenty of chances to explain what that means in practice.
Our experienced Fort Lauderdale child custody lawyer breaks down what the statute requires, what recent decisions show, and what evidence can move a judge off 50/50.
What the Presumption Requires Under Section 61.13
Section 61.13(2)(c)1. of the Florida Statutes presumes that equal time-sharing is in a child’s best interests. A parent who disagrees must prove otherwise by a preponderance of the evidence, which means more likely than not. Unless the parents agree on a schedule, the judge must weigh every factor in Section 61.13(3), which lists 20 of them, and make specific written findings.
The presumption is a starting line, not a finish line. Changing an existing order still requires a substantial and material change in circumstances.
What Appellate Courts Are Saying
Because Broward County appeals go to the Fourth District, its rulings carry special weight locally. Recent decisions point in a few consistent directions:
- Findings matter. In October 2025, the Fifth District reversed a time-sharing schedule because the judgment never referenced the best-interest factors. The case went back for proper findings.
- Past mistakes aren’t enough on their own. In a 2026 decision, the Fourth District affirmed a trial court’s conclusion that equal time-sharing wasn’t in a child’s best interests, noting that even if the presumption applied, it was easily rebutted on that record. But the court reversed the complete denial of time-sharing, because nothing showed that time with that parent would harm the child. It described a total denial as functioning like a sanction.
What Evidence Actually Overcomes 50/50
Evidence tied to the statutory factors and to your child does the heavy lifting. Examples include:
- Records of domestic violence, abuse, abandonment, or neglect, which the judge must acknowledge in writing under Section 61.13(3)(m).
- Proof of substance abuse that affects the child’s environment under Section 61.13(3)(q).
- Evidence that distance and school travel make equal time unworkable under Section 61.13(3)(e).
- Documentation of the child’s developmental needs and the value of continuity under Section 61.13(3)(s) and (d).
- A track record of who handled school, medical, and daily routines before and during the case under Section 61.13(3)(o).
General complaints about the other parent rarely carry the burden. Judges want proof of how a schedule affects your child.
Facing a Time-Sharing Dispute? Contact Our Experienced Fort Lauderdale Child Custody Lawyer Today
Florida’s equal time-sharing presumption is powerful, but it isn’t automatic. At Vanessa L. Prieto Law Offices, we help parents across Broward County build evidence-based cases for or against 50/50, and our experienced Fort Lauderdale child custody lawyers can evaluate your situation. Contact us today to request a consultation.
Source:
https://www.flsenate.gov/Laws/Statutes/2026/61.13 https://flcourts-media.flcourts.gov/content/download/2461458/opinion/Opinion_download?documentVersionID=6380a84a-986b-4570-80a2-5a0b9f31bd4c https://flcourts-media.flcourts.gov/content/download/2494729/opinion/Opinion_2025-2779.pdf